TNZ- 11/13/2023- Jason with Scott Bushnell … again… speak about needs to change. Speaking at a level where Jason explodes in frustration !
Summary & Full Timestamped Transcript Below
- [00:03 → 02:39]
Introduction and Context: Maui’s Current State Post-Disaster
The show opens with a lighthearted introduction referencing the date and the idea of “changing the paradigm.” The host introduces guest Scott R. Bushnell, who is affiliated with Maui and the website alohaswimlessons.com, highlighting his diverse experience. The discussion quickly pivots to the state of Maui post-Hurricane Lana (referred to as “Lina” in transcript), focusing on the community’s resilience (“Maui strong”) and the visible challenges, such as people camping on Kopali Beach. The host notes that there is longstanding unmet need for housing and social support that predates the recent wildfire disaster but has now become more acute. - [02:39 → 06:22]
FEMA, Insurance, and Housing Crisis - Critical issues related to FEMA aid and insurance payouts are discussed. Many homeowners, including multi-generational families who inherited homes, find themselves trapped between insurance companies and FEMA, with disputes over coverage and payment responsibilities.
- The insurance industry is reluctant to pay, pushing responsibility onto the federal government due to the scale of the disaster. This results in a bureaucratic stalemate with residents stuck in the middle.
- There is confusion and frustration among residents, and legal advice is recommended before dealing with insurance companies.
- The presence of unidentified groups camping on the beach adds tension, reflecting deeper systemic issues rather than the immediate disaster alone.
- Behind the scenes, legal and political maneuvers involving the mayor and utility companies suggest complexity in addressing the crisis.
- The media landscape is briefly mentioned, noting that mainstream news outlets charge for access, while the show’s platform (Maui Neutral Zone on public access TV) provides free, community-focused coverage.
- [06:22 → 11:10]
Economic and Social Transformation of Maui: From Plantation to Tourism - The conversation transitions to the historical economic shift from sugar cane plantations to tourism, which has driven significant changes in Maui’s economy and housing.
- Originally, plantation and hotel developers built employee housing alongside infrastructure improvements (wastewater, water systems). However, over time, housing affordability and availability failed to keep pace with wage growth and community needs.
- The existing housing stock and laws have not adapted to allow local workers to afford living in Maui, leading to a deepening crisis.
- The local economy now includes tech workers and remote employees returning to Maui, representing a potential source of stability and growth, but comprehensive workforce development and education reform are needed to diversify and support this new economy.
- The island’s isolation and dependency on imports exacerbate vulnerability, highlighting the urgency of developing a self-sustaining community model.
- [11:10 → 15:56]
Housing Affordability and Community Challenges - There is a clear gap between the demand for affordable housing and the supply, worsened by regulatory hurdles and the aftermath of natural disasters.
- Some local businesses, especially in upcountry and Kihei, report record sales, but this contrasts sharply with the widespread housing crisis and homelessness, underscoring uneven economic impacts.
- Discussion on FEMA’s limited shelter capacity (127 beds) compared to the number of displaced individuals highlights the insufficiency of current aid efforts.
- The service industry workers face challenges despite the influx of FEMA renters in hotels because these renters do not contribute significantly to local businesses beyond lodging.
- The core question posed: Where is the money to fund housing and recovery coming from? This remains a critical but largely unresolved issue.
| Topic | Detail/Issue |
|---|---|
| FEMA shelter beds | Only 127 beds available for wildfire displaced persons |
| Hotel impact | Hotels receive FEMA funding but auxiliary businesses see limited benefit |
| Local business performance | Some sectors thriving, others devastated |
| Funding source | Unclear; public funds limited; private investment needed |
- [15:56 → 22:02]
Regulatory Barriers and Labor Shortages Hindering Recovery - The conversation identifies government regulations and labor licensing as major bottlenecks to rapid housing construction.
- Specifically, Hawaii’s contractor licensing requires five years of apprenticeship under a licensed general contractor, preventing outside labor forces from coming in quickly to build new homes.
- This protectionist policy, while intended to safeguard quality and local jobs, significantly delays rebuilding efforts in an emergency context.
- The speakers advocate for temporary suspension or modification of these regulations specifically in the wildfire burn zones to expedite recovery.
- The need for a coordinated effort involving landowners, financiers, and construction professionals is emphasized.
- Examples from other states where construction crews and materials are brought in rapidly are cited as models.
- [22:02 → 29:54]
The Role of Big Money, Landowners, and Government Leadership - The discussion turns to the pivotal role of wealthy landowners and financial institutions who have the resources to build but face obstacles due to regulations and government inertia.
- The speakers call for political leadership (mayor, governor, legislature) to enact special laws and emergency measures that allow fast-tracking of housing construction while maintaining code compliance.
- There is frustration expressed over the slow pace of government response and a call for public involvement to push politicians to act.
- The speakers envision a collaborative framework where private investment and public authority combine to solve the housing crisis.
- The idea of putting a regulatory moratorium or emergency legislation on the ballot to empower this process is introduced.
| Stakeholders | Potential Role |
|---|---|
| Private landowners | Provide land and capital |
| Financial institutions | Fund construction projects |
| Government (Mayor, Governor) | Enact laws, suspend regulations temporarily, coordinate efforts |
| Public | Advocate and hold leadership accountable |
- [29:54 → 36:51]
Practical Solutions: Modular Homes and Streamlined Construction - Modular homes and prefab construction methods, which produce minimal waste and quick assembly, are proposed as effective solutions.
- The challenge remains that current local regulations complicate or prohibit the use of such methods, requiring permits and compliance that slow down projects.
- The speakers emphasize that building codes should be flexible in emergency zones but still ensure safety and quality.
- They urge those with connections and influence in government and finance to step forward and help break down these barriers.
- The conversation stresses the importance of integrating private sector efficiency with public sector oversight to expedite housing delivery.
- [36:51 → 39:22]
Community Media and Call to Action - The show encourages listeners to engage with community media like Maui Neutral Zone and Akaku Public Access TV for ongoing information and advocacy.
- The hosts reiterate the need for grassroots involvement and sustained public pressure to ensure that emergency housing becomes a reality.
- The tone shifts to a call for responsible, respectful dialogue and action rather than complaint alone.
- Personal commitment from the hosts to continue pushing this agenda is expressed.
- [39:22 → 48:14]
Upcoming Community Events and Broader Context - Announcements about local events such as Akaku’s Community Connection Day and a screening of the cult classic horror-comedy Blood Diner are shared, reflecting active community engagement.
- Historical and cultural reflections on Maui’s arts and music scene link community identity to recovery efforts.
- There is also a brief discussion about the national issue of underpaid wildland firefighters, highlighting the importance of properly funding emergency services on Maui and beyond.
- The speakers note Hawaiian Electric’s controversial early power shutoff on the wildfire day, hinting at ongoing investigations and public scrutiny.
- [48:14 → 56:37]
Summary, Commitment, and Vision for Maui’s Future - The hosts summarize the key issues: housing shortage, regulatory barriers, need for private investment, and political will to enact emergency reforms.
- There is a strong emphasis on collaborative problem solving that includes all sectors of Maui society — from displaced residents to business owners to government.
- The conversation closes on a hopeful note, with Scott Bushnell committing to lead efforts toward concrete solutions and inviting public participation via the show’s call-in line.
- The hosts reaffirm that Maui is “not only Lahaina strong but Maui strong” and stress the importance of vision, unity, and action to create a sustainable future.
- The show ends with encouragement to keep the dialogue going and to use media platforms to maintain momentum.
Key Insights and Themes
- Housing crisis on Maui is deep and multifaceted, exacerbated by natural disasters but rooted in decades of economic and regulatory challenges.
- Insurance and FEMA aid processes are complex and often ineffective for displaced multi-generational homeowners.
- Regulatory and licensing laws, while protective in normal times, are major obstacles to rapid rebuilding in emergencies.
- Private landowners and financial institutions hold key resources but lack enabling policies and coordinated leadership to act quickly.
- Community involvement, media transparency, and political will are crucial to breaking the stalemate.
- Innovative construction methods (modular homes) and emergency legislation could dramatically speed recovery.
- There is a need to balance emergency flexibility with safety and quality standards.
- Local workforce development and economic diversification are key to long-term sustainability.
- Public engagement and advocacy are essential to hold government and private actors accountable.
Timeline Table: Key Topics and Events
| Timestamp | Topic | Summary / Action Point |
|---|---|---|
| 00:03 – 02:39 | Introduction & Maui’s current post-disaster state | Community strength; visible housing crisis; Kopali Beach campers |
| 02:39 – 06:22 | FEMA and insurance issues | Conflicts between insurers and FEMA delaying aid to homeowners |
| 06:22 – 11:10 | Economic shift from plantation to tourism | Historic lack of affordable housing linked to economic changes |
| 11:10 – 15:56 | Housing affordability and uneven economic impact | Limited FEMA shelter capacity; service workers struggling |
| 15:56 – 22:02 | Regulatory and labor constraints | Licensing laws preventing rapid construction; call for emergency suspension |
| 22:02 – 29:54 | Role of big money and government leadership | Need for laws empowering private investment; political action required |
| 29:54 – 36:51 | Modular homes and streamlined construction | Prefab methods as solution; regulatory hurdles remain |
| 36:51 – 39:22 | Community media and public involvement | Call to action for grassroots advocacy and ongoing engagement |
| 39:22 – 48:14 | Local events and broader emergency services context | Community events; firefighter pay issue; Hawaiian Electric power cut inquiry |
| 48:14 – 56:37 | Summary and commitment to solutions | Hosts’ pledge to lead efforts; vision of Maui strong and sustainable |
Definitions and Concepts
| Term | Definition / Explanation |
|---|---|
| FEMA | Federal Emergency Management Agency, responsible for disaster aid |
| Modular Homes | Prefabricated houses built off-site and assembled on location quickly |
| Protectionist Licensing | Regulatory policies that limit entry to professions to protect locals |
| Emergency Legislation | Temporary laws enacted to expedite processes during crises |
| Workforce Development | Training and education to prepare workers for evolving economic sectors |
Call to Action and Contact Information
- Listeners are encouraged to call in and participate via 808-873-3435
- Visit MauiNeutralZone.com and Akaku.org for updates and community media content
- Engage with local government and advocate for emergency regulatory reform and housing solutions
- Support events like Akaku’s Community Connection Day and local cultural initiatives to strengthen community bonds
This summary captures the core content, insights, and calls to action from the video transcript, reflecting the urgent housing and recovery challenges on Maui and the proposed pathways toward solutions.
Full Transcript
